A recent research study conducted by UCC and TCD researchers which was commissioned by the Minister for Justice, into the operation of the ‘in Camera’ rule in Family Law Proceedings has been published.
Family Law proceedings in Ireland are conducted “in camera” so to ensure the privacy of those involved in these proceedings. Confidentiality is crucial to these families, in particular for children, however, it also limits public scrutiny and understanding of the family court operations. In 2013, changes to the rule allowed members of the press to attend family courts under strict conditions with the aim of bringing the process to light while maintaining privacy. Despite this, challenges persist regarding the rule’s application and its effects on the justice system’s openness.
The research report was published in May 2025 and Minister O’Callaghan said: “This is an important piece of research which details the perspectives of many stakeholders regarding the current understanding and operation of the in-camera rule in family law proceedings. Importantly, it includes the views of those who have been parties in such proceedings.”
The findings of the report demonstrate that the parameters of the rule have not been defined and delineated in legislation which has led to a wide interpretation of the rule by the Judiciary. Worryingly, this has left people feeling silenced and isolated.
The report calls for a pragmatic approach and makes a series of recommendations. Minister for Justice Jim O’Callaghan has said that in order to address some of these concerns his Department is establishing the Private Family Law Reporting Project and this will be issued in the coming weeks with further policy reforms expected by the end of 2025.
The proposed reforms represent significant steps towards a more transparent and trustworthy family justice system in Ireland.
if you have away further queries please do not hesitate to contact Brendan Dillon, Emma Dillon, Alice Downey or Simone Murray on 01 296 0666
